Psychology Today or Google Business Profile: where should a therapist put their effort?
Have both. Every therapist should have a Psychology Today profile and a Google Business Profile, because they reach different people. Treat them differently, though. Psychology Today is a directory you rent. Your Google Business Profile is the listing people see when they search for a therapist near them, and it is free.
What Psychology Today does well.
People who already know the directory search it on purpose, often filtering by issue, insurance and location. A full profile there brings in clients who are ready to book. It is a paid subscription and the page belongs to Psychology Today, so if you stop paying, it goes.
What a Google Business Profile does that Psychology Today cannot.
It puts you in Google’s own local results, which people see without visiting any directory. Google ranks local results on relevance, distance and prominence, and says more reviews and positive ratings can help local ranking (Google Business Profile Help: Tips to improve your local ranking on Google). A complete, verified profile is how you show up in that map.

The rules that trip therapists up.
From Google’s own guidelines (Google Business Profile Help: Guidelines for representing your business on Google):
- A P.O. box or mailbox is not an acceptable address.
- A virtual office you rent but do not work from is not eligible.
- If you see clients only online, or go to them, you are a service-area business and should hide your address.
- Your profile name should be your real-world name. Adding keywords such as “Anxiety Therapist Dallas” to it can get the profile suspended.
- Use as few categories as possible, chosen for what the business is.
Reviews and confidentiality.
Therapists can ask for reviews. They just have to be sensitive about how they ask, and who. If a patient chooses to say they were a patient in a review on your Google Business Profile, that is their choice: they are sharing their own health information, so you are not breaking HIPAA. The risk is in your reply. Never confirm that someone was a patient or mention anything about their care. If you are a psychologist, the APA Ethics Code says not to solicit testimonials from current clients, so ask former clients only.
What I would do, in order.
- Set up and verify the Google profile, following the rules above.
- Set up or keep a full Psychology Today profile as well, and make the two listings match: same name, same address or service area, same phone.
- Link both to a page on your own site for each thing you treat, so Google and potential clients see the same picture everywhere.
If you want this done for your practice, see local SEO and mental health and therapy marketing. For a real example, read the North Texas DBT Associates case study.